Wednesday, February 26, 2020

Human Rights and Value Sensitive Design

Value Sensitive Design (VSD) is focused on values that center on human well-being, human dignity, justice, welfare, and human rights. This means that computer programs implemented in the past few years have been used to ensure and protect your rights as a person. It was made to help people stay safe and secure within programs. Now while VSD has actually been a part of many different programs and people's lives in general there is some explaining to do as far as how it works and what exactly it does.





Value Sensitive Design has been used in a wide range of research and designs such as the bias in computer systems, universal access, Internet privacy, informed consent, ubiquitous sensing of the environment and individual rights, certain urban planning processes, social and moral aspects of human-robot interaction, privacy in public, and designer values in the design process. With all that said it has been used in a variety of ways to solve a variety of problems, these are all linked to making a process that will be fair for all. But it is not only a process that makes things fair for all it is also used to make programs that are more pleasing to the eye and in line with what people believe. For example VSD is used in line with the Google search engine to make some results more human rights friendly. Recently Google has been accused of hiding White Power websites deep within a list of human rights articles, now there are other things that play into this, but as far as the use of VSD these results are made to support human rights and justice among other things. While some people see this a way to bury the existence of these groups it can also been seen as a prolonging of the whole of the human race, a welcoming wish to see human rights at work. While these lines of thinking can go on and on deeper and deeper into true human rights, the use of VSD is clear and has been implemented into our everyday lives.





With that in mind, I think that this process of Value Sensitive Design should be used as much as possible. As such there is also some fine-tuning that needs to be done, this program is simply an assist rather than a full-on solution. The bigger picture is still out there, and people could sit down and talk about fairness and their own personal rights forever, but VSD is being used as it is now.There is still plenty of work for people to do to make sure that it's implications are just and fair for all. However, I do believe that just as there are plenty of ways to police people in real life there should be just as many ways to police them online and while using interlinking systems. You can see this process at work already, it has taken hold in many ways and I believe that it should continue to do so. However, there are plenty of people who don't believe that this is true and in a world entrusted to many that are completely unaware of this issue I believe that it will take years to implement fully.

4 comments:

  1. Hi, Conner!

    Not sure why, but I'm unable to find your original post to make a comparison. So I'll read the post normally.

    I think you did a good job making use of industry anecdotes to support your description of VSD. And in this context, the conclusion made sense! That said, the post felt a bit academic to me.

    The writing was all 'safe,' the intro didn't really pull me in, etc. Furthermore--and this probably falls into the realm of personal opinion--the middle and last paragraph were too long for me. You can break them up with whitespace for added emphasis. Thanks for posting!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hi Conner,

    I believe that this post is an improvement from your original post and is longer, but kind of confusing to read. I couldn't find a central theme to the post and while you did explain some things well, it read as randomly placed ideas and didn't really pull me in. The post could have been improved if you incorporated some of the readings from class as well as perhaps giving a better definition of Value Sensitive Design. You brought up an example of Google pulling certain search results but didn't really explain the context. Maybe you could have given bad examples of Value Sensitive Design in the real world and provided ways to improve them.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Hi Connor,
    You have definitely done some work to improve this version of your post, though finding the older version was made more difficult because you changed the title slightly. There are some clear ethical issues that could be discussed with VSD, and while you mention the impact with its implementation at Google and briefly discuss further social and ethical impacts later, most of your post seems to focus on VSD's implementation. The addition of a quote from one of the readings would have given your paper an anchor into these issues and would have been a welcome addition.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I thought this was a really great read and a big improvement from your last post. but I couldn't find a main theme to the post, hope you can make clear on that. One suggestion I have is maybe you could breaking up the longer paragraphs into shorter chunks will be a good move Other than that, this was a great read and a good improvement. Good job!

    ReplyDelete

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.